|
The contract between the University of California and
the Manhattan District of the Corps of Engineers (MED) to operate
Project Y, Los Alamos Laboratory, was not signed until April 15, 1943,
after the project was already under way. It was the first such
contract between them.
A rudimentary agreement was first laid out in a
letter from Irwin Stewart on Jan. 23, 1943, and called for an Office
of Scientific Research and Development (OSRD) contract with the
University of California for "certain investigations to be directed by
Dr. J. R. Oppenheimer," at a cost of $150,000 covering the period Jan.
1, 1943, to July 31, 1943.
Such contracts had been the standard means of
mobilizing university researchers to work in installations such as the
radiation laboratory at the University of California, its namesake at
the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the University of
Chicago's metallurgical laboratory. Several such contracts had been
established between the University of California and the OSRD.
Robert M. Underhill, the secretary of the regents of
the University of California, understood that the contract would be
similar to the other OSRD contracts at Berkeley and, on that basis,
agreed with UC President Robert Gordon Sproul to accept the letter of
intent on Feb. 10, 1943.
"There was some very informal discussion after that
with Dr. Oppenheimer," Underhill later wrote, "and it is my
understanding that as a preliminary matter we were to provide
personnel service, traveling expenses and to cover charges then being
expensed by Princeton University under a similar letter of intent. It
was some time later before permission was granted to inform me as to
where this project would be located. My only knowledge up to that time
being that it would not be in the State of California. É It very
definitely seemed to be that the University, as a corporation, was to
be almost a straw man in the proceedings, but to this the University
never agreed."
Enter the MED. The decision to transfer work on the
atomic bomb from the OSRD to the MED had been made by OSRD head
Vannevar Bush and James Bryant Conant, Harvard University president
and chairman of the S-1 committee (the committee that oversaw all
phases of work on nuclear weapons) of the OSRD early in 1942, and the
district was organized in the summer of that year to take charge of
the developmental aspects of the project, especially the manufacture
of Uranium 235 and plutonium. Gradually, the MED took over those
contracts relating to the bomb.
On Feb. 13, 1943, Oppenheimer and Gen. Leslie Groves
met with Underhill to negotiate a long-term contract to operate Los
Alamos Laboratory.
The fact that this occurred after the site,
equipment and men for the project had been selected suggests that the
contract was an afterthought. Indeed, Underhill found that Oppenheimer
had already hired D. P. Mitchell from Columbia University to take
charge of purchasing at Los Alamos and that he was arranging to hire a
business manager.
Underhill rejected the business manager proposed by
Oppenheimer because, he felt, "it would be better to have someone who
knew something about University organization and its general business
arrangements." In his discussion with Mitchell, Underhill got the
impression that "the University was to be more or less in the position
of banker and officially little more." It was in fact, a pact between
those who would only work for a civilian project and Groves, who
wished the bomb design to be done under military auspices.
Bringing in the University of California in 1943
made recruiting for the work of the Laboratory easier. Underhill,
however, insisted on more UC involvement. The regents of the
University of California were concerned that the project was located
outside the state of California. Underhill approached the finance
committee of the regents who instructed him to investigate the
liabilities to which that might expose them. Underhill was told only
that the Los Alamos project would never include more than 250 people
and that it would have an annual budget not exceeding $7,500,000.
Groves convinced Sproul that the contract was "the best solution to a
crucial problem."
UC was experienced in research and could do the job.
As Groves later admitted, he had a "big problem in getting good
people" because "the scientific resources of the country, particularly
in this general area, were already fully engaged in important war
work. Because they were civilians, the scientists had complete freedom
in their choice of jobs." A university employer would be more
acceptable than the military or industry.
Nevertheless, Groves clung to the notion of military
control, and insisted that once development was begun, the military
would take over the project. At least one scientist, Robert Bacher,
who headed the physics division at Los Alamos Laboratory, submitted a
resignation that would be effective upon that transition.
On Feb. 20, in a meeting in the Biltmore Hotel in
New York with Conant and Groves; Groves' deputy, Col. Kenneth D.
Nichols; I. I. Rabi of Columbia and the M.I.T. Radiation Laboratory;
Samuel Allison of the metallurgical laboratory of the University of
Chicago; and Robert Wilson of Princeton University who would lead the
cyclotron group at Los Alamos, Underhill learned that the Army, not
the OSRD, would be the agency that would oversee the Los Alamos
contract. He was no more pleased to learn this than the scientists had
been. "I suggested that some other university might be found to carry
on the activity.
"There was some slight discussion of California
Institute of Technology," said Underhill, because Oppenheimer had
served there as well as at UC, the University of New Mexico and the
University of Chicago. "However, there seemed to be no general desire
on the part of the Army that any institution but the University of
California be requested to do the work," continued Underhill, because
Oppenheimer and other scientists had worked at the Berkeley Radiation
Laboratory and because UC was already receiving many contracts worth
millions of dollars for related work on electromagnetic separation.
Underhill left the meeting after telling those
present that UC would be perfectly satisfied to have any other
university handle the contract.
The next day, Oppenheimer approached him outside
Grand Central Station in New York, told him that everyone concerned
still wanted UC to have the contract and asked him to meet with Groves
in Washington. On Feb. 22, he met with Groves and agreed.
A letter of intent was drafted by the Army and
signed by Underhill March 3, 1943. The detailed contract required five
days to negotiate, from April 15 to April 20, 1943. Underhill
succeeded in obtaining the conditions traditional in OSRD contracts.
Because the work at Los Alamos had already started, Underhill and the
Army gave up the attempt to include an agreement for negotiation with
the Army in the contract, and although the main part of the contact
was signed on April 20, the negotiation agreement was not added until
a year later.
For reasons of security, UC had no representative at
Los Alamos with authority comparable to Oppenheimer or the military
commander. Only Oppenheimer, Lawrence, McMillan and other members of
the University of California faculty recruited for "Project Y"
understood the true implications of the work. Neither Underhill nor
the regents were told the true purpose of the project. It was not
until November of 1943 that Ernest Lawrence, the director of the
University of California Radiation Laboratory who had helped to
organize Los Alamos, came into Underhill's office, shut the door and
asked: "You know what they're doing down in Los Alamos?" When
Underhill confessed he did not, Lawrence told him that an atomic bomb
was being designed there. Underhill was forbidden, however, to tell
the regents.
To ensure UC control and protect the secrecy of Los
Alamos, material for the Laboratory was routed through UC's purchasing
office in Los Angeles, which shipped it on to Los Alamos, where
Mitchell ran the procurement office.
The purchasing office was organized March 16, 1943,
and branch offices were set up in April 1943 in New York and Chicago
to handle emergency requests. Eventually, some 300 UC employees
staffed these offices, including 32 buyers and 22 expediters. They
purchased approximately $400,000 worth of items (about 6,000) per
month during the war.
The arrangement created difficulties and delays that
did not diminish as the Laboratory expanded. Orders sent to the Los
Angeles office had to be carefully written, because the employees of
the purchasing office had no direct contact with the user groups at
the Laboratory, no knowledge of its work and therefore could not
understand its significance or urgency.
Oppenheimer and his staff occasionally complained
about inefficient and inexperienced buyers, but as these offices were
seriously understaffed and deliberately kept ignorant of the purpose
of their work, the inefficiency was probably inherent in the
circumstances.
The University of California connection also helped
stock the shelves of the Laboratory's library, which was organized and
catalogued by Charlotte Serber, the wife of Robert Serber, the
theorist who gave the first set of lectures at Los Alamos in April
1943. UC lent 1,200 books and 50 journals to start the library. New
books were purchased through Los Angeles, which placed the orders
through the library at the University of California. During the course
of the war, the number of books rose to 3,000, journals to 160 and
1,500 microfilm reproductions were made.
Although the University of California was kept
largely in ignorance about the nature of the project at Los Alamos
until after the war, at which time it tried to terminate the contract,
Lawrence, Sproul and Underhill finally agreed to continue to operate
the Laboratory for the MED's successor, the Atomic Energy Commission,
in 1947. The contract, although born and swaddled in secrecy, was
adequate to operate the Laboratory and to complete its wartime
mission.
Copyright Notice
For Scientific and Technical Information Only
Copyright © 1998-2001 The Regents of the University
of California.
For All Information
Unless otherwise indicated, this information has been authored by
an employee or employees of the University of California, operator of
the Los Alamos National Laboratory under Contract No. W-7405-ENG-36
with the U.S. Department of Energy. The U.S. Government has rights to
use, reproduce, and distribute this information. The public may copy
and use this information without charge, provided that this Notice and
any statement of authorship are reproduced on all copies. Neither the
Government nor the University makes any warranty, express or implied,
or assumes any liability or responsibility for the use of this
information.
LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL LABORATORY
An Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer
|